marc marc
marc
marc marc
blog about books journalism speaking contact

What’s Areva trying to hide?

Take a look at the full-page ad from Areva below. Notice the symbols: American flag, people at work doing who knows what. Notice the words that stand out: American clean-energy solutions, thousands of American jobs.

So what two words are missing from the ad?

arevaad

In case you can’t read the text, here it is:

AREVA is America’s largest supplier of innovative solutions for carbon-free energy. AREVA is the biggest employer in our sector with 6,000 highly skilled American workers in 20 states. Thousands more jobs depend on us through our 5,000 American suppliers. AREVA’s investments in America’s energy infrastructure also means new jobs. Our planned $2.5 billion Eagle Rock enrichment facility will help create another 5,000 jobs and enhance our nation’s energy security. And the new $360-million AREVA Newport News facility, a partnership with Northrup Grumman, will add another 500 high-wage U.S. jobs building state of the art EPR reactoirs for America and the world.

Reader of this blog, it should go without saying, are smart and well-informed so by now you have figured out what two words are missing.

One is nuclear.

The other is France.

Areva is, of course, a big French multinational company (13,1 billion euros in 2008 revenues) that develops and builds nuclear reactors around the world, mines uranium and disposes of nuclear waste. (Yes, it has some windpower and lots of transmission assets as well, but its core business is nukes.) Areva is building new nuclear plants in China and India, and it wants to develop them here in the U.S.–which must why it is waving the red, white and blue, making questionable claims about jobs and promising to “enhance our nation’s energy security.” I assume that’s a reference to the U.S. and not France, but who knows?

Now, I don’t really think Areva is trying to hide anything. But what’s going on here? Is nuclear energy so unpopular that the company won’t use those words in its ads? (This page came from The New Republic but I assume the campaign is running in other publications aimed at government officials and opinion leaders.) Is France a negative, too? The words “America,” “American” or “U.S.” appear eight times.

You have probably figured out by now that I don’t think much of this ad. Here’s why:

1. I’m skeptical about the “clean energy jobs” argument. I don’t think the potential for job creation should drive energy policy. If it did, solar on every rooftop would be a lot better idea that building nukes or wind farms.

2. I like France. I’m a U.S. citizen but I’m not ashamed to admit that (like Areva) I was born in Paris.

3. I’m open-minded about nuclear power. Why would a nuclear power company not talk about nukes?

Like a growing number of environmentalists, I think the climate crisis means that we need to take low-carbon nuclear power seriously.In fact, I’d love to hear thoughtful arguments from Areva about why the nuclear industry wants protection from liability, why it needs loan guarantees, why proliferation shouldn’t be a worry and what will happen with waste. That’s an important conversation, one we should be having and one in which Areva’s contributions would be welcome.

Instead we get a slogan: “Building a new American generation for energy generation.” Whatever that means.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Twitter
  • email
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon

4 Responses to “What’s Areva trying to hide?”

  1. Dan Yurman says:

    Marc,

    Areva’s US HQ office is just down the road from you in Bethesda,MD. Why don’t you take a stroll over there and ask them? I’d be interested in their dialog with you especially since the company is making an effort to reach out to energy bloggers on nuclear energy issues.

    Better still, dial in for the next monthly conference call with energy bloggers, which is on the record, and then, if you still think they have something to hide, throw all the rocks, or shoes :-) you want.

    Finally, please stop by the winter meeting of the American Nuclear Society (ANS) being held in Washington, DC, next month. On Nov 17th at 6 PM Areva is planning to meet with a dozen or so of the more prolific energy bloggers in the U.S. They plan to talk about their lessons learned in communicating with the blogger community. If nothing else, there will be free beer.

    Hope to see you there.

    Regards, Dan

  2. Marc says:

    Thanks, Dan, I look forward to the blogger call, the bloggers event at the American Nuclear Society and to learning more about Areva.

    As I wrote, I don’t literally think Areva is hiding anything, at least not with this ad. I’d just like to see them advance the conversation about energy and climate in a mature way.

  3. Beth says:

    I wonder if the problem is also a culture issue. Many non-Americans believe we only care about America, which would suggest down-playing any foreign company’s involvement in US energy. Also, marketing efforts are often inconsistent or ineffective because companies don’t fully understand the other culture. Some American’s are protectionist and prefer “build/buy America” or US jobs. Recent questions about EDF, France shipping nuclear waste to Russia is another concern. I believe more transparency, accuracy in nuclear PR and more green, sustainable solutions are essential for us all. Thank you for posting this and helping to keep us better informed.

  4. Mike Starry says:

    Brian H., please cite your source(s) for Spain’s “horror” green job killing 2.2 jobs elsewhere and prove those jobs were not going to die anyway. It seems that you are mixing economic statistics to prove your point. Did your minister also tell you that Jesus thought that Al Gore’s movie “An Inconvenient Truth” was propaganda? Oh, and why are you hiding your last name?

    “If we go back to the beginning, we shall find that ignorance and fear created the gods; that fancy, enthusiasm, or deceit adorned them; that weakness worships them; that credulity preserves them and that custom, respect and tyranny support them in order to make the blindness of men serve their own interests. If the ignorance of nature gave birth to gods, the knowledge of nature is calculated to destroy them.”
    - Baron D’Holbach 1723-1729, Paris

Leave a Reply